La Punition

(aka The Punishment) 1973

France/Italy. a Ma Produzione/Labrador Films/Fox-Lire. Written by Pierre-Alain Jolivet & Richard Bohringer, from the novel by Xavière. Directed by Pierre-Alain Jolivet. Starring Karin Schubert, Amidou, Claudie Lange. Color, 95m. Bootleg.

LEFT: Before the chaos:  Karin enjoying a lyrical shower in the Madame’s bathroom. (For more photos click on the title above.)

Bill Landis and Michelle Clifford

"They decided that I would be punished. And what punishment should I choose to be inflicted on myself... "What to me" the punishment "?

 

The humiliation of captive locked up in a seedy Lyon hotel, undressed, abandoned in a sordid room... Her anguish as soon as the light dies out. Her resignation in front of the customers who paid to appease on her their particular defects. Her hatred against the procurers who inflict this sanction. And her revolt when she hears the cries of Gloria, the other captive one made insane of suffering "I did not want to save anybody. I simply wanted to make Gloria known, and through it, the others, all the others... "

 

-Xavière, La Punition (1969)

 

Xavière is not Xavière Hollander, but a French prostitute who wrote several books about being in the life.  Her autobiographical novel about the dangers of the profession, La Punition (literally, the punishment), was a huge bestseller in France.  Adapting it for the screen was as difficult as wedding de Sade's fantastical scenarios to grim contemporary reality.  Miraculously director Pierre-Alain Jolivet performed this alchemical marriage, making La Punition into a classic film.

 

La Punition was a hit in France and was highly notorious because of its graphic S&M content.  It was never released in the United States, and you wonder why.  Was it the unconventional narrative structure or is its explicit sexuality? Perhaps both. The film became legend, and stills from it were reproduced in Eurosleaze-slanted sex-in-cinema books.  Three decades after its release the film is finally reaching American audiences through collectors' video companies.

La Punition is a great S&M film, but runs much deeper.  It opens and closes in death. The four principal characters are self-aware about what they're doing and are playing for keeps.  We meet them in a pre-credit sequence at a murder.  The habitués of a sleazy nightclub stare in silence, passive witnesses experiencing mild shock rather than terrified.  Manuel (Georges Geret) lies dead, his throat cut and face covered with blood. Françoise (Claudie Lange) kneels to his side and quivers.  Raymond (Amidou) rushes up to the scene, looks in horror, and grabs Britt (Karin Schubert).  He's in such a rush to flee that he almost crashes through a glass door.  They get in his car and they flee down the highway.  An ominous looking blond man follows.

 

Overpass signs and eerie instrumental Euro-pop set the hypnotic mood that lasts through the movie.  The credits unfold as the color turns negative and presents foreboding images of what had transpired.  The narrative then emerges in skip-time, starting near the present and flashing back to the events leading up to it. The brief excerpt quoted from Xaviere's novel above also serves as one of many ways of summarizing the movie.

Britt and Raymond sit in aftershock at a crowded diner off the road.  A bratty kid throws a beach ball, upsetting a waitress' tray and several things on neighboring tables, including that of the protagonist..  Raymond smirks.  The laughing kid gets a glass of water poured over his head by his mother, immediately making the connection between sadism and anger.  A john recognizes Britt and attempts a free reconnection.  He follows her into the restroom, where he boorishly sticks his hands up her dress.  She ignores and him rejoins Raymond.

 

Then it's back to the past, where Britt and Raymond attend a hip happening.  A pinball machine has mannequin legs extending from it in a coital manner.  A joker in a devil's outfit falls to the floor as he plays table hockey against Britt and Françoise.  A fox is part of the dinner buffet.  The guests include various art-world hipsters and journalists.


Karin, beautiful, before the true
victimization starts

La Punition demands you invent the internal lives of its protagonists through an amazing power of suggestion.  It becomes clear from queues and gestures that Britt is a foreign prostitute who came to Paris.  Françoise is a madam who has been married to her business partner Manuel.  Manuel is a gangster acting as overlord to a vice ring.  Raymond is a pimp who works for Manuel.  He's Moroccan, which has the same racial overtones of a black pimp in America.  This is an upper class vice ring, as Manuel's entourage is as socially acceptable as having Madame Claude and French whores at the soiree. 

 

The situation is further clarified in the next scene, as Françoise takes Britt clothes shopping.  Britt submissively strips before her in the dressing room and puts on a form fitting black one-piece dress.  Back at her low lit and luxurious apartment, Françoise tries to keep Britt intimidated and off balance.  She flashes such grotesque collectibles at Britt as a dildo held by a prosthetic hand stuck with pins in a glass case.  "Is Raymond your guy?" she asks Britt casually.  Raymond arrives, followed by Manuel.  At dinner Manuel sits at the head of the table, flanked by minions on each side, reinforcing the chess motif.  Britt's glass is filled in close-up and the soundtrack reinforces the visual image of urine filling a toilet.  The waiter spills food near her, almost deliberately, but cleans it up.  Afterwards, Britt strips before Manuel, who sits on the couch and sternly looks over the merchandise.


One of the typical clients about to sexually terrorize
Karin in the seedy hotel room

Topless dancers move in the background of Manuel's nightclub-brothel.  A customer does a rape number on Britt. The john complains about her performance as she's left in shock, undressed on the dirty floor.  The guy pays up, and Manuel stuffs some of the money into Raymond's breast pocket. Like always, Raymond looks a little remorseful but takes the money.

Britt cries to Françoise in her apartment.  "Why?"  Françoise phones Manuel and says that, "she's refusing."  Raymond, looking extremely depressed, walks Britt through a dank hotel lobby occupied only by its staff.  Manuel takes Britt to a room, which is empty except for a bedframe with springs and a cabinet containing a variety of whips, dildos and other devices.  He smacks her across the face, orders her to strip, collects her clothes and hands her a white smock.  She's locked in.

 

A succession of S&M fiends arrives to abuse her.  A businessman chases her down and whips her with two white cat o' nine tails.  He leaves her tied in the bathroom barely conscious, her body covered in welts, her face bloodied. 

 

Raymond briefly holds her in his arms, then suddenly fists her battered pussy.  There is a constant drone of horrific shrieks from the room next door.  Britt is briefly allowed out of her room as her neighbor, Gloria, tries to crawl away.  Karin looks at Gloria in terror; she has two black eyes and cannot stand.  She collapses and Raymond casually drags her by the ankle back to her room.

A man enters with a suitcase containing a neatly wrapped red bishop's outfit.  Britt stands nude before him as he verbally humiliates her while wearing the robe.  He pulls it up and fucks her in the ass.  He then relaxes in the bar, sketching on a pad.

Britt grasps at straws of tenderness.  She has a wordless encounter with the bellboy and blows him after she dresses in his clothes.  The passage of time is indicated by all the woodchips in the room made by her clawing at the walls.  The hotel owner feeds her and gives her a trinket from Raymond. It's the only token of any affection


Karin dresses down for her boss, Georges Geret

in her universe, and she clings to it.  An anxious man arrives in the room and motions for her to whip him.  Asking Britt to be dominant in this situation is the straw that breaks the camel's back.  She overturns the bed at him and hurls the sex toys at the cabinet.  After this session she mentally regresses to tossing a rubber ball against the wall.

 

          Manuel pays an inspective visit to see if the training as been effective.  Britt sits nude under an overcoat, trembling and teary eyed as Raymond anxiously looks to his boss for approval.  Back at Françoise's apartment, Britt wears wearing a wig, makeup and clothing that mimics Françoise's look.  Britt walks out, and meets Raymond in a bar.  She takes the wig, makeup, and rings off, leaving them in the bathroom sink.


Karin as dominatrix with the innkeeper voyeuristically
savoring on her appearance in this role

Britt needs Raymond and constantly looks to him for affection he's incapable of giving.  As a minority foreigner in France, Raymond knows he has a well-paying job.  Like a drug dealer, he doesn't get high on his own supply.  The sadistic urge is subconsciously part of his attraction to Britt, because she can take a lot.  However, he is so inured to his life, he can only show her pity and empathy.

Flash-forward to the present, currently a desolate area enveloped by rocks. The blond hitman points a gun at the john who had battered Gloria at the hotel. He marches his prey into a meat freezer and swiftly deals him a cleaver blow to the chest.

 

Suddenly we're at the orgy party leading up to the pre-credit murders.  Gloria angrily storms over to Manuel and says "Bastard. You think you're funny?"  Suddenly, she breaks a glass, cuts Manuel's throat and gouges him in the face.  There is no surprise or resistance on Manuel's part. Throughout the film he's been merciless vice lord who demands women do as he commands, pure sadism, but with one percent terminal masochism.  When he goes, it's in the most theatrical and public manner possible.  

 

Françoise falls trembling to the floor before him.  Raymond hustles Britt into a car and they flee.  He brings her to the deserted cave-like area.  Raymond cradles Britt and the hitman shoots her to death.  Raymond emits a primal scream and weeps, her corpse in his arms.

          On one obvious level, La Punition is portrays a worst nightmare for sex professionals - you'll be abused and then snuffed because your proficiency in S&M draws a crowd.  Moving under the surface, and more shockingly, it's been a death trip all along.  You always get the impression the gangsters Manuel works are observing events from above.  Many people witness Manuel's murder, so it's less of a matter of eliminating the witnesses than a situation of disposing of people that knew what happened at the hotel.  And, most disturbingly, why else would Raymond bring Britt to a deserted area that's a perfect setup for snuff?

Everybody down to the most subsidiary characters in the film is brilliantly cast.  The four leads are great character players who work as an ensemble.  Georges Geret brings his association from numerous French underworld roles.  France's national Moroccan treasure Amidou has a screen presence like no other actor.  He fearlessly plays out Raymond's multiple pathologies:  as underlying beholden to an older thug; as a desperate man whose life situation and own kinks have finally engulfed him.  A shocker is the casting of director Pierre-Alain Jolivet's wife, Anne, in the brief but pivotal role of Gloria; read into it what you may.


Karin, working at Georges Geret’s club,
complete with crucifix, before her punishment

La Punition is Eurosleaze superstar Karin Schubert's finest role.  Her Britt is beautiful and willingly vulnerable, but also strong and never pathetic.  Schubert's presence is haunting, and it's almost like she became Britt for the rest of her life.  Karin's history dates back to the late 1960s, and she has always been admired for her exhibitionistic skills.  She also appeared in films like the Richard Burton vehicle Bluebeard but never became an established star, remaining firmly entrenched in the exploitation world in films like Black Emmanuelle.  When she was middle-aged she turned to doing hardcore porn for the money.  Laura Gemser, her Black Emmanuelle co-star, has mentioned that Karin once attempted suicide.

 

Director Jolivet, the son of a prominent orchestra conductor, only made three movies - Le Grande Ceremonial, from a script by surrealist Fernando Arrabal; and Haute Surveillance, an all-female adaptation of Genet's terminal prison drama, Deathwatch.  His work in La Punition indicates great talent, and it's a surprise he didn't make more films.  Jolivet accomplishes an aesthetic innovation in that La Punition sustains the mood of a surrealist dream state while interpreting the reality of personal story, down to its last bitter detail.  He has created a perfect memory piece, the type that Robbe-Grillet theorized about more than actually made, where past and present slowly collide.

 

La Punition's hypnotic quality is further enhanced as its narrative emerges internally.  The characters and situations are so sharply and unapologetically defined by the cast and director that they need not discuss the whys and wherefores of their being.  The movie shows their external actions and everyday exchanges without need for exposition in actions or dialogue. And this is the key to what makes La Punition a great movie.  It involves you as much as the characters. You're with them for the entire ride and know what they've about.  You can imagine their pasts and how their actions fit in with a larger scheme.


Amidou and Karin:  Pimpin’ ain’t easy,
especially when you’re a Moroccan in Paris

And you may even identify with one--or any of the characters--too closely.  If you have ever worked in the vice world, La Punition is like seeing reflections of yourself in glass fragments, or like walking through the funhouse mirror of your mind.  It is the ultimate film for those who accustomed to observing their life from a slight distance and who are not psychiatrically inclined.

Sign my Guestbook from Bravenet.com Get your Free Guestbook from Bravenet.com

Return To Contents